← Commercial research

OPERATIONS · DEMAND & CAPACITY

Operational planning under uncertainty

What capacity balances service, cost and uncertainty?

Evaluated synthetic demonstrationExecutive summary ↓

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY / THE DECISION IN PLAIN LANGUAGE

Lower staffing cost comes with a service decision.

Evaluated synthetic study · no actual client outcomes

The uncertainty-aware plan reduced simulated 52-week cost by $59,028 (7.0%) versus the buffer rule. It served 99.38% of demand, versus 99.83% for the buffer rule.

$59,028Lower simulated 52-week cost
99.38%Demand served
52 weeksHeld-out operational evaluation

What a leader should do next

Set an acceptable service floor, validate shortage costs, then test the schedule in shadow mode before operational use.

What could change the decision

After a sudden sustained demand increase, the estimated savings fell to about $80 per week and the interval included zero. This is a one-site synthetic study with simplified labor constraints.

Explore the interactive results ↓

01 / BUSINESS DECISION

Start with the decision.

Lock seven days of regular staffing for a single service site, then use limited daily overtime after demand is observed. Choose a feasible plan under a weekly staffing budget and daily ramp limits, with explicit costs for labor and unserved requests.

02 / PRACTICAL IMPLICATION

What the evidence can support.

Over 52 held-out synthetic weeks, the stochastic plan costs $59,028 less than a feasible 20% buffer rule—a 7.0% reduction. Service decreases from 99.8% to 99.4%. After a sustained demand surge, the savings interval includes zero. Leaders must decide what service floor and shortage costs are acceptable before preferring the lower-cost plan.

03 / EVIDENCE

Staffing cost and service tradeoffs.

Evaluated synthetic demonstration

A complete rolling forecast-and-decision evaluation over 156 synthetic weeks, with 52 final test weeks. All policies obey the same daily staffing bounds, weekly worker-day budget and within-week ramp limits. The optimizer is checked against exhaustive enumeration on small cases.

Interactive results · the executive summary above remains the fixed headline comparison.

SYNTHETIC SERVICE SITE · 52 HELD-OUT WEEKS · IDENTICAL RESOURCE CONSTRAINTS

Stable process · cost and service together

The stochastic plan lowers cost against the buffer rule, with a small reduction in demand served. The perfect-information result is an unattainable lower bound.

Mean weekly realized cost · service levels differ
20% buffer rule$16,314
Point-forecast plan$15,216
Stochastic plan$15,179
Perfect-information bound$14,710
Same held-out weeks, staffing limits and overtime options
Policy52-week costDemand servedWeekly savings vs buffer95% savings interval
20% buffer rule$848,31699.83%$0$0 to $0
Point-forecast plan$791,20899.46%$1,098$782 to $1,412
Stochastic plan$789,28899.38%$1,135$805 to $1,474
Perfect-information bound$764,90499.40%$1,604$1,223 to $1,967

Savings intervals use a paired four-week moving-block bootstrap over one 52-week synthetic history. The perfect-information planner sees future demand and cannot be deployed. No actual business savings are claimed.

Forecasts and service economics

The demand model’s aggregate error is 6.0%, versus 7.3% for the seasonal-naive forecast. Its nominal 80% daily ranges cover 73.6% of held-out demand, showing that uncertainty calibration still needs attention.

Re-optimize the stochastic plan at each unserved-unit penalty
Penalty per unit52-week cost¹Demand servedRegular worker-daysOvertime worker-days
$12$768,73292.73%5,8600
$24$789,28899.38%6,176206
$48$795,49299.83%6,233231

¹Each row uses a different cost definition; compare service/resource choices rather than interpreting cross-row cost differences as savings.

04 / DATA

Know where the evidence comes from.

Original synthetic daily service demand, version synthetic-capacity-v1. Demand includes weekday and annual seasonality, trend and correlated weekly shocks. There are no real staffing records. Unserved demand is lost rather than queued; staffing does not change demand. Calibration uses archived seven-day forecast-error vectors from earlier weeks.

The source includes a data dictionary, fixed configuration and seed, original data generator, observed CSVs, evaluation outputs and source/data hashes. Read the data dictionary ↗

Inspect full results and provenance hashes ↓

05 / METHODOLOGY

Match the method to the design.

Fit a regularized trend/seasonal/recent-level model at each weekly cutoff. Add up to 52 past weekly error vectors to the new forecast, retaining within-week error dependence. Minimize expected labor plus shortage cost with exact dynamic programming over day, cumulative worker-days and previous-day staffing. Evaluate all feasible overtime choices as daily recourse. Compare the realized decisions with practical baselines under identical constraints.

Evaluation design

  • Compare ridge demand forecasts with seasonal-naive forecasts using only information available before each week.
  • Evaluate a projected 20% buffer rule, point-forecast optimization and stochastic planning on the same held-out weeks.
  • Report realized cost, service, shortages, overtime and unused capacity; use a perfect-information lower bound, demand-shock tests and shortage-cost sensitivity.

References motivate the methods. These study-specific implementations do not claim every assumption or theoretical guarantee of the cited work.

06 / LIMITATIONS

Conditions that matter.

  • Regular staffing is 8–26 workers daily, at most 135 worker-days weekly, and changes by at most four workers between adjacent days within a week.
  • One worker supplies 12 units per day. Regular cost is $120 per worker-day; up to five overtime workers cost $180 each; unserved units cost $24 each.
  • No cross-week ramp, skill mix, labor-law, absence, shift-length or multisite constraints are modeled.
  • All demand and calibration errors available to a plan occur before its cutoff. The perfect-information planner is an evaluator-only benchmark.

This completed simulation does not establish actual cost savings or staffing feasibility for an employer. Marginal 80% demand intervals cover only 73.6% of stable held-out days, and shifts can degrade performance. The four-week block-bootstrap cost interval describes one synthetic history. A lower-cost plan may deliver lower service; neither forecast accuracy nor cost alone is a sufficient operating criterion.

07 / CODE & NEXT STEPS

Reproduce the result.

PYTHON 3.11.16 · LOCKED NUMPY / SCIPY · FIXED SEEDS
git clone https://github.com/mpgibb/operational-planning.git
cd operational-planning
uv sync --frozen
uv run python -m unittest discover -s tests -v
uv run python study.py
git diff --exit-code -- data results

Automated checks and synthetic evaluation are complete; Michael’s independent technical review is pending.

Next step

Agree on a service floor, shortage economics and actual staffing constraints with an operating owner. Backtest an authorized demand history and run a shadow schedule before changing staff assignments.

Privacy preferences

Security verification and inquiry delivery are essential. These optional choices do not affect them.

Optional services may remain unavailable until configured. No raw chat, search or contact text belongs in analytics. Read the privacy notice.